1 00:00:36,694 --> 00:00:38,420 Good evening 2 00:00:39,767 --> 00:00:42,993 Regarding your daughter Liat We have new news 3 00:00:43,017 --> 00:00:44,022 Yes 4 00:00:44,809 --> 00:00:48,993 ...let me start here 5 00:00:49,017 --> 00:00:52,827 The army has collected information ...which shows 6 00:00:52,851 --> 00:00:56,244 Liat by terrorists Arrested in the Gaza Strip 7 00:00:56,268 --> 00:00:59,268 and apparently alive 8 00:01:00,351 --> 00:01:03,035 ...I don't know the exact details 9 00:01:03,059 --> 00:01:07,226 ...Waysa waysa waysa 10 00:01:09,934 --> 00:01:12,952 Okay, if possible, say it again 11 00:01:12,976 --> 00:01:16,576 New series of information obtained 12 00:01:16,600 --> 00:01:21,160 which shows Liat in the Gaza Strip Arrested 13 00:01:21,184 --> 00:01:24,035 and apparently alive 14 00:01:24,059 --> 00:01:27,214 , by the way, about your son-in-law Avi 15 00:01:27,359 --> 00:01:30,268 We have not received any specific information 16 00:01:33,029 --> 00:01:34,454 ok 17 00:01:42,013 --> 00:01:47,100 "Captivity of Liat" 18 00:01:51,365 --> 00:01:55,886 on October 7, 2023" "An Israeli-American couple named Liat and Aviv Atzili 19 00:01:55,910 --> 00:02:00,917 During the Hamas attack on southern Israel. "They were kidnapped 20 00:02:02,763 --> 00:02:10,342 Two weeks later, filmmakers associated with Liat "They are making a documentary about his family's experience 21 00:02:12,733 --> 00:02:27,733 00:03:03,078 or God 25 00:03:06,612 --> 00:03:09,612 "Judah - Liat's Father" 26 00:03:19,010 --> 00:03:21,206 Do you want a picture of a buffalo? 27 00:03:21,637 --> 00:03:23,461 Is Buffalo still here? 28 00:03:23,597 --> 00:03:25,641 Not very well maintained 29 00:03:29,613 --> 00:03:32,613 "Khaya - Liat's mother" 30 00:03:33,149 --> 00:03:34,273 Wait, Judas? 31 00:03:34,298 --> 00:03:35,464 what is - come here - 32 00:03:40,823 --> 00:03:42,033 or God 33 00:03:58,758 --> 00:04:01,270 The person who joined us Judah is Benin 34 00:04:01,294 --> 00:04:03,606 A man from New Jersey who They live in Israel now 35 00:04:03,630 --> 00:04:07,526 Their daughter Liat and their son-in-law Aviv Being captured by Hamas 36 00:04:08,450 --> 00:04:12,980 Can you explain a little more to us? What happened on the 7th of October? 37 00:04:13,397 --> 00:04:18,045 Kibbutz by about 200 commandos was attacked 38 00:04:18,069 --> 00:04:21,889 They went from house to house They executed men, women and children 39 00:04:22,213 --> 00:04:24,607 And they set fire to the houses 40 00:04:24,961 --> 00:04:31,491 The casualties at the end of the day were as follows Forty of the 400 members of the kibbutz were killed 41 00:04:32,792 --> 00:04:36,146 And seventy people have been kidnapped and being transferred to Gaza 42 00:04:37,463 --> 00:04:39,744 How do you deal with this issue? 43 00:04:40,800 --> 00:04:48,013 We, we must maintain our ability So that we can effectively deal with this calamity 44 00:04:48,359 --> 00:04:50,145 ...this case for us 45 00:04:51,999 --> 00:04:54,664 It was very tiring... 46 00:04:54,688 --> 00:04:56,415 Both for me and my wife 47 00:04:57,316 --> 00:05:02,780 The whole focus of us and our grandchildren is that Bring their parents back from Gaza 48 00:05:04,406 --> 00:05:07,576 Can you tell me a little about your daughter Liat? And talk to your son-in-law Aviv? 49 00:05:07,994 --> 00:05:13,684 Liat and Aviv at a young age Getting to know each other 50 00:05:13,708 --> 00:05:16,051 During youth activities 51 00:05:16,553 --> 00:05:19,491 Liyat is a teacher of history and civil sciences 52 00:05:19,516 --> 00:05:22,855 He is also in the field of Holocaust studies are also specialized 53 00:05:22,935 --> 00:05:26,039 And Aviv was also a skilled artist 54 00:05:26,363 --> 00:05:29,715 and the manager of an agricultural garage 55 00:05:30,390 --> 00:05:34,871 Yehuda, did you hear anything about their captivity? 56 00:05:34,895 --> 00:05:37,415 Where are they kept? Or details like this? 57 00:05:37,439 --> 00:05:38,740 no 58 00:05:40,193 --> 00:05:41,920 We wish the best for you and your family 59 00:05:41,944 --> 00:05:43,287 thank you 60 00:05:47,141 --> 00:05:52,139 "House of Judah and Chata - Kibbutz Shumerat" 61 00:05:52,371 --> 00:05:57,811 It's so hard that we don't know what happened to him Or we can't talk to him 62 00:05:57,835 --> 00:05:59,646 In fact, we can't do anything 63 00:05:59,670 --> 00:06:02,506 ...very nerve-wracking and 64 00:06:04,091 --> 00:06:05,485 I don't want to say this 65 00:06:05,509 --> 00:06:09,138 But our biggest concern is that He is no longer between us 66 00:06:11,724 --> 00:06:16,770 Or Liat or Aviv That one of them is not killed 67 00:06:24,570 --> 00:06:27,656 In general, I want it I have control of the situation 68 00:06:28,324 --> 00:06:31,677 And now, a situation has arisen that We have absolutely no method control 69 00:06:31,901 --> 00:06:35,799 and control the situation A bunch of crazy people 70 00:06:36,123 --> 00:06:39,543 It doesn't matter if they are on the Israeli side And what is the Palestinian side? 71 00:06:40,127 --> 00:06:44,298 And the result is All this killing and destruction 72 00:06:45,174 --> 00:06:48,844 And this situation It makes me angry 73 00:06:54,183 --> 00:06:58,350 We with an unprecedented force We will attack our enemies 74 00:06:58,934 --> 00:07:00,679 I emphasize 75 00:07:01,142 --> 00:07:03,267 This is just the beginning 76 00:07:03,559 --> 00:07:06,993 Israeli defense force quickly He will use all his power 77 00:07:07,017 --> 00:07:08,976 To destroy the capabilities of Hamas 78 00:07:10,011 --> 00:07:16,271 We will avenge this black day that they brought upon Israel And its citizens imposed "we will take it by force". 79 00:07:17,290 --> 00:07:21,103 What is Israel's highest priority right now? 80 00:07:21,127 --> 00:07:25,256 I must say that returning the captives home More important than anything 81 00:07:25,756 --> 00:07:29,652 It seems that Netanyahu's government It has been concluded that 82 00:07:29,676 --> 00:07:32,305 This issue is much more important than Invasion of the Gaza Strip 83 00:07:32,721 --> 00:07:36,725 I do not expect that all these captives return to their homes 84 00:07:43,774 --> 00:07:47,297 Bibi (Netanyahu) knows that here 85 00:07:47,321 --> 00:07:52,391 An opportunity to realize a long-standing dream Every right-wing politician exists 86 00:07:52,866 --> 00:07:56,662 Never take advantage of a crisis Do not miss to advance your goals 87 00:07:58,872 --> 00:08:03,994 Its goals are to preserve the government annexation of the West Bank to Israel 88 00:08:04,318 --> 00:08:07,472 To make his allies happy 89 00:08:07,506 --> 00:08:10,926 The release of captives is not part of Bibi's goals 90 00:08:59,068 --> 00:09:00,836 Hello Yehuda, how are you? 91 00:09:01,042 --> 00:09:06,284 We are considering sending a delegation to America 92 00:09:06,308 --> 00:09:10,134 to keep this issue at the top of the news 93 00:09:10,178 --> 00:09:15,614 I don't know myself as anyone , especially in the media to be effective 94 00:09:15,639 --> 00:09:17,389 but ok 95 00:09:21,154 --> 00:09:22,982 "Mikey Bergman - consultant for prisoner exchange negotiations" 96 00:09:23,207 --> 00:09:27,140 I contacted my Qatari colleagues 97 00:09:27,165 --> 00:09:31,243 and on the eighth day of October clearly telling me 98 00:09:31,267 --> 00:09:34,284 The issue of captives is considered an important problem for them 99 00:09:34,553 --> 00:09:36,959 and they are going to solve it 100 00:09:36,984 --> 00:09:40,368 Of course, Hamas and Israel They cannot have direct negotiations 101 00:09:40,392 --> 00:09:44,203 Qatar's problem is that they cannot do this Do it for Israel 102 00:09:44,228 --> 00:09:47,508 But this work for the President of the United States Doing 103 00:09:47,865 --> 00:09:51,134 The goal is that they Take advantage of your American citizenship rights 104 00:09:51,159 --> 00:09:54,826 And do something that the subject of the release of captives Become a concern of the United States 105 00:09:55,285 --> 00:09:56,593 We have a chance 106 00:09:56,618 --> 00:10:01,129 We want that opportunity Use it to return captives 107 00:10:06,625 --> 00:10:10,683 Judah and I in different ways We deal with problems 108 00:10:11,213 --> 00:10:14,174 i feel I have to stay here with my grandchildren 109 00:10:15,301 --> 00:10:23,569 But Yehuda feels like turning to the government America is the only way to free captives 110 00:10:24,560 --> 00:10:27,687 I don't know, Judah How much influence can it have? 111 00:10:28,855 --> 00:10:33,527 But if someone is going to talk to politicians That's not me 112 00:10:35,988 --> 00:10:38,657 In short, Judah is more skilled in conversation 113 00:10:47,207 --> 00:10:51,587 What will happen to Liat and Aviv? It's not my hand 114 00:10:53,046 --> 00:10:57,026 But I am not a person to sit in a corner And let anything happen 115 00:10:58,969 --> 00:11:03,390 This is not the future I imagined for my children 116 00:11:05,392 --> 00:11:07,927 Which war ever? Did it end well and happily? 117 00:11:08,312 --> 00:11:11,040 Actually, because Liat is smarter than me 118 00:11:11,064 --> 00:11:13,876 He realized this a long time ago 119 00:11:13,900 --> 00:11:17,070 Much earlier than me 120 00:11:38,113 --> 00:11:42,155 00:11:53,776 With leaders, politicians and... MPs meet 124 00:11:54,400 --> 00:11:57,903 To present the human side of this story 125 00:11:58,445 --> 00:12:01,924 In my opinion, the struggle for peace and reconciliation 126 00:12:01,948 --> 00:12:07,472 The best way to pay tribute It will be to Liat and Aviv 127 00:12:07,496 --> 00:12:10,043 Neta, especially your story 128 00:12:09,667 --> 00:12:12,167 {\an8}"Neta - Liat and Aviv's little son" 129 00:12:10,067 --> 00:12:15,342 When Hamas people were in your room Very strong and effective 130 00:12:15,493 --> 00:12:19,025 Always the best way to advance the story There is, it is not clear 131 00:12:19,049 --> 00:12:20,959 The best way to present the case 132 00:12:21,117 --> 00:12:24,477 And this is very important Let's do the right thing 133 00:12:24,823 --> 00:12:31,493 I am not going to kidnap my parents And thank them for killing my acquaintances 134 00:12:31,594 --> 00:12:32,594 ...or 135 00:12:33,000 --> 00:12:35,887 Or robbing my house and life Or shooting my dog 136 00:12:35,912 --> 00:12:37,516 This... no 137 00:12:37,540 --> 00:12:38,947 Yeni... their father's grave 138 00:12:39,451 --> 00:12:41,534 They must die 139 00:12:43,509 --> 00:12:47,569 I know that probably many innocent people They exist in the Gaza Strip 140 00:12:47,649 --> 00:12:50,866 We can't destroy the whole place, but 141 00:12:51,594 --> 00:12:57,181 What happened is to recognize that Who makes the innocent difficult? 142 00:12:58,791 --> 00:13:02,940 I have no reaction after such a disaster i understand 143 00:13:03,510 --> 00:13:05,763 On the other hand What happens when this is over? 144 00:13:05,787 --> 00:13:06,805 ...Daddy 145 00:13:06,829 --> 00:13:11,286 Rest assured, what has been is not forever It can't be like that 146 00:13:11,310 --> 00:13:12,662 It is not permanent 147 00:13:12,686 --> 00:13:15,540 Dad, let's think about it Where are Liat and Aviv now? 148 00:13:15,564 --> 00:13:17,083 Let's focus on that matter, Dad 149 00:13:17,107 --> 00:13:20,086 There is no need for this trip events between Israel and Palestine 150 00:13:20,110 --> 00:13:22,422 I don't think Neta will disagree ... so leave it 151 00:13:22,446 --> 00:13:24,615 Yes, but we have to do both 152 00:13:25,407 --> 00:13:27,636 very hard - OK, you do both - 153 00:13:27,660 --> 00:13:30,530 I focus on Liat and Aviv 154 00:13:30,954 --> 00:13:32,708 Benjamin Netanyahu 155 00:13:32,733 --> 00:13:33,866 ...Dad, it's no use - I have to do it - 156 00:13:33,891 --> 00:13:37,392 OK, but there is no point in doing this Explain to everyone here 157 00:13:37,417 --> 00:13:38,968 Let's just focus 158 00:13:39,463 --> 00:13:41,149 Honestly, I don't know 159 00:13:41,173 --> 00:13:43,485 Your or my opinion does not matter at all 160 00:13:43,509 --> 00:13:45,069 Let's do just one thing 161 00:13:45,093 --> 00:13:46,988 I am an Israeli citizen 162 00:13:47,012 --> 00:13:48,930 In fact, my opinion is important 163 00:13:49,473 --> 00:13:53,001 And the prime minister is trying to To relieve the burden of this responsibility 164 00:13:53,525 --> 00:13:56,946 And we must not allow that Get out from under this work 165 00:13:57,147 --> 00:13:59,616 Honestly, you want to do the same thing I keep my wits about me 166 00:13:59,650 --> 00:14:01,866 I understand that, okay 167 00:14:01,901 --> 00:14:03,422 very funny 168 00:14:03,446 --> 00:14:04,475 all right 169 00:14:07,115 --> 00:14:11,596 My father has been for a long time Dissatisfied with Israel's ways 170 00:14:11,620 --> 00:14:15,915 This is how if you are from where you live If you are not satisfied, leave there 171 00:14:15,957 --> 00:14:18,227 This is my way of coping It was under those conditions 172 00:14:18,251 --> 00:14:20,587 I couldn't bear it In short, I left there 173 00:14:21,714 --> 00:14:28,738 I think all the people present in Israel They have someone they lost because of Palestine 174 00:14:28,762 --> 00:14:31,907 And I'm sure it's the same with the Palestinians 175 00:14:31,931 --> 00:14:35,077 All of them have someone who Losing it because of the Israelis 176 00:14:35,101 --> 00:14:40,114 So how can people under these conditions ...and in such a cycle of violence 177 00:14:40,138 --> 00:14:43,199 coexist with each other? 178 00:14:45,215 --> 00:14:46,383 I don't know 179 00:14:46,862 --> 00:14:51,931 00:14:57,615 You know, in this country People distribute posters of kidnapped people 182 00:14:57,639 --> 00:15:00,669 And now that issue has become that Let's find out who is tearing them apart 183 00:15:00,905 --> 00:15:03,405 {\an8}"Gabriel Groisman - political strategist" 184 00:15:01,612 --> 00:15:04,412 Because an opposition movement has started They tear the poster 185 00:15:04,536 --> 00:15:06,817 The only person who can tell your story Tell me who you are 186 00:15:06,842 --> 00:15:10,655 And you are here doing that for people which can influence the situation 187 00:15:10,679 --> 00:15:15,577 And I hope and pray that each and every one of you Feel a little empowered by being here 188 00:15:15,701 --> 00:15:17,710 Let's move, come 189 00:15:22,112 --> 00:15:23,792 "!Bring back our families!" 190 00:15:23,983 --> 00:15:27,137 These people came here and their families To give up in the most difficult possible conditions 191 00:15:27,161 --> 00:15:29,758 to meet you and your colleagues To explain their problem to you 192 00:15:29,782 --> 00:15:31,649 And that their problems are heard 193 00:15:31,674 --> 00:15:33,366 Well, let's start with Neta 194 00:15:31,690 --> 00:15:33,790 {\an8}"Senator Rick Scott - Florida" 195 00:15:33,870 --> 00:15:35,322 I am Neta Atzili 196 00:15:35,347 --> 00:15:38,674 I was in Nir Oz One of the kibbutz that was attacked 197 00:15:39,249 --> 00:15:43,104 I was alone there and suddenly I heard a gunshot 198 00:15:43,128 --> 00:15:47,358 When they entered my apartment I said to myself that I am done 199 00:15:47,382 --> 00:15:50,361 They try to open Muhammad's door 200 00:15:50,385 --> 00:15:52,321 And I had to resist them 201 00:15:52,345 --> 00:15:53,656 Safe room, right? - safe room - 202 00:15:53,680 --> 00:15:54,681 yes 203 00:15:54,890 --> 00:15:57,034 You kept the door To prevent them from entering? 204 00:15:55,375 --> 00:15:57,575 {\an8}"Senator Joe Manchin - West Virginia" 205 00:15:57,058 --> 00:15:59,083 That's right - yes - 206 00:15:59,895 --> 00:16:02,248 Thank you very much - God bless you - 207 00:16:02,272 --> 00:16:05,415 Surely God is protective Otherwise you would not be here now 208 00:16:06,192 --> 00:16:08,337 I wish I knew the solution 209 00:16:08,361 --> 00:16:10,338 I just want my parents back 210 00:16:10,405 --> 00:16:12,391 right, right 211 00:16:11,515 --> 00:16:13,715 {\an8}"Senator Mitch McConnell - Kentucky" 212 00:16:14,442 --> 00:16:17,036 Okay, thank you Good luck to you all 213 00:16:27,558 --> 00:16:29,909 It is very difficult to solve this problem Explain again and again 214 00:16:29,933 --> 00:16:34,808 But I feel good I can be effective 215 00:16:36,272 --> 00:16:38,016 I hope so 216 00:16:40,936 --> 00:16:44,666 I am a personal trainer And I have been living in Portland for 9 years 217 00:16:43,308 --> 00:16:45,508 {\an8}"Senator Ron Wyden - Oregon" 218 00:16:44,690 --> 00:16:48,628 I am here about my sister and our son-in-law The pair were kidnapped 219 00:16:48,652 --> 00:16:52,841 I am also here for my two nieces to be saved 220 00:16:52,865 --> 00:16:56,135 And I just want their parents to come back 221 00:16:56,159 --> 00:16:59,705 I am very proud that you are here 222 00:17:00,038 --> 00:17:03,058 You know the truth, my parents too Escape from the Nazis 223 00:17:03,083 --> 00:17:04,442 Of course not all of them 224 00:17:02,667 --> 00:17:04,667 {\an8}"Senator Ron Wyden - Oregon" 225 00:17:04,435 --> 00:17:06,806 We lost some of them in Kristalnach* [The night of the destruction of Jewish property and the starting point of the Holocaust] 226 00:17:06,831 --> 00:17:11,359 And the challenge of bringing your families back 227 00:17:11,383 --> 00:17:13,259 The main issue for me 228 00:17:18,015 --> 00:17:20,099 I hate this job, I'm serious 229 00:17:20,183 --> 00:17:22,161 I don't want to ask for help 230 00:17:22,185 --> 00:17:25,915 I also think that all those with We met, they are doing their best 231 00:17:25,939 --> 00:17:29,067 In short, I don't know what is the point of these meetings 232 00:17:29,735 --> 00:17:34,982 I say, I will do this Because I do it for my sister 233 00:17:35,851 --> 00:17:41,451 ...but this is my favorite method Not for help 234 00:17:48,211 --> 00:17:53,401 I am saying this on behalf of my daughter and son-in-law And I will say about the release of prisoners 235 00:17:53,417 --> 00:17:55,617 {\an8}"Senator Chris Van Hollen - Maryland" 236 00:17:53,425 --> 00:17:55,236 I think this is the most important message 237 00:17:55,355 --> 00:17:59,094 After all these adventures are over "The question is, 'Well, now what?' 238 00:17:59,514 --> 00:18:04,902 Reconciliation with the Palestinians Probably the most important thing 239 00:18:04,926 --> 00:18:10,067 It can be in the long run lead to the improvement of the situation 240 00:18:12,046 --> 00:18:14,508 Let them come to their own conclusions 241 00:18:14,676 --> 00:18:16,819 But this issue will eventually become political 242 00:18:16,996 --> 00:18:18,157 No! 243 00:18:18,091 --> 00:18:20,291 {\an8}"Einat Halloy Levin - political consultant" 244 00:18:18,898 --> 00:18:20,792 no - no, not now - 245 00:18:20,817 --> 00:18:24,833 The main thing is that you Affect their feelings 246 00:18:26,332 --> 00:18:30,772 I would like to have special conditions Abduction of my daughter and son-in-law 247 00:18:30,796 --> 00:18:33,673 Add dimensions and other details 248 00:18:34,340 --> 00:18:36,868 In our conversation with President Biden 249 00:18:36,992 --> 00:18:40,806 Their ultimate goal at some point in time It is a two-state solution 00:18:55,421 Returning the captives to their homes, right? 255 00:18:55,445 --> 00:18:59,282 We don't even know that Our loved ones are alive or dead 256 00:18:59,783 --> 00:19:02,035 Do you want to think about it for a moment? 257 00:19:03,870 --> 00:19:06,123 The rest of the issues should be dealt with at another time be postponed 258 00:19:07,916 --> 00:19:12,105 Apart from telling our personal stories To influence the feelings of these people 259 00:19:12,129 --> 00:19:13,630 What practical cases are there? 260 00:19:13,655 --> 00:19:16,006 You are not a politician You are not here for this 261 00:19:16,048 --> 00:19:18,555 You are here to inform them And give them strength 262 00:19:21,888 --> 00:19:24,742 I know my daughter He is a history teacher 263 00:19:24,766 --> 00:19:26,995 He is also one of the guides of "Yad Vashem* Foundation". [Foundation for the preservation of Holocaust artifacts and documents] 264 00:19:27,019 --> 00:19:31,206 He cares about the pain and suffering of others 265 00:19:31,230 --> 00:19:35,419 And my feeling is that By promoting this message of peace and reconciliation 266 00:19:35,443 --> 00:19:37,779 I pay tribute to my daughter 267 00:19:40,862 --> 00:19:44,862 00:21:44,941 "I said, "My brother One of the Jewish values is that 301 00:21:44,966 --> 00:21:47,050 Take responsibility for your actions 302 00:21:47,075 --> 00:21:48,385 But this is not happening, is it? 303 00:21:48,409 --> 00:21:50,938 You see, they have people's attention They distract from this reality 304 00:21:50,962 --> 00:21:54,433 , that Israel's policies The biggest reason for our problems is people 305 00:21:54,457 --> 00:21:58,437 This conflict between our common civilization And brutality is common to them 306 00:21:58,461 --> 00:22:00,338 Civilization must win 307 00:22:11,346 --> 00:22:13,898 What is your grandfather's opinion about all these issues? 308 00:22:14,259 --> 00:22:20,354 Well, that politically Completely disagree with these people 309 00:22:20,392 --> 00:22:21,826 but 310 00:22:22,019 --> 00:22:24,463 We need help 311 00:22:24,988 --> 00:22:26,052 right 312 00:22:26,296 --> 00:22:29,938 I feel here A lot of responsibility on my shoulders 313 00:22:30,744 --> 00:22:34,304 Honestly, this work today I did it a thousand times, but 314 00:22:34,395 --> 00:22:36,331 Like this time It was not in front of so many people 315 00:22:42,642 --> 00:22:44,537 Thank you Rabbi ...very fast now 316 00:22:44,562 --> 00:22:49,017 I want Neta Atzili I invite the son of Liat and Aviv to the stage 317 00:22:49,042 --> 00:22:52,908 That is, those who were kidnapped And we want him to speak a few words to us 318 00:22:52,932 --> 00:22:53,933 neta 319 00:22:56,061 --> 00:23:01,074 I visit my parents all day And I was texting my friend 320 00:23:01,598 --> 00:23:04,084 To see if they are still alive 321 00:23:04,277 --> 00:23:07,613 And it was around noon I never heard from my mother again 322 00:23:10,533 --> 00:23:16,449 While we are spending time here They are still there 323 00:23:16,474 --> 00:23:18,917 And we can do anything Let's use it to help them 324 00:23:20,377 --> 00:23:21,478 thank you 325 00:23:32,597 --> 00:23:34,867 I am a member of the Kibbutz - It doesn't matter - 326 00:23:34,891 --> 00:23:36,303 Yes, I know, it doesn't matter 327 00:23:36,328 --> 00:23:38,831 ...but you should notice the differences - What help can we do? - 328 00:23:38,912 --> 00:23:41,732 listen Do you want to do something important? 329 00:23:41,856 --> 00:23:44,478 You must state that in Israel 330 00:23:44,502 --> 00:23:49,082 We need religious institutions Separate from the government 331 00:23:49,406 --> 00:23:54,013 ...leave them I have no position against 'men of God'* 00:28:28,479 This is propaganda 411 00:28:37,456 --> 00:28:40,528 "Save people's lives" "Cease fire now! 412 00:28:40,863 --> 00:28:43,842 I was completely confused 413 00:28:43,866 --> 00:28:49,848 In the last two weeks I encountered a lot of different messages and strategies 414 00:28:49,872 --> 00:28:53,257 ...I was a little surprised that 415 00:28:50,782 --> 00:28:53,282 {\an8}"Meeting of families of Israeli-American prisoners" 416 00:28:53,466 --> 00:28:57,873 Regarding the issue of 7000 prisoners Israel has a very brief reference 417 00:28:58,297 --> 00:29:03,529 Or also to Netanyahu's personal situation It was not mentioned much 418 00:29:03,553 --> 00:29:08,516 Bibi, in turn It prevents many events 419 00:29:09,601 --> 00:29:12,283 And you can't ignore this 420 00:29:12,472 --> 00:29:13,642 What is his plan? 421 00:29:13,667 --> 00:29:16,023 His plan is to get out of prison 422 00:29:16,434 --> 00:29:18,251 ...well, so he doesn't want to 423 00:29:18,276 --> 00:29:20,898 No matter how long this conflict continues ...more 424 00:29:20,934 --> 00:29:24,160 Is the plan to continue this war? - yes - 425 00:29:25,533 --> 00:29:28,869 We clearly know that Our relatives are in danger 426 00:29:30,190 --> 00:29:33,735 So let's make it responsible to do something 427 00:29:34,375 --> 00:29:38,948 And if it means that the United States has to Take him to the edge of the abyss 428 00:29:38,973 --> 00:29:41,567 So let it be done This is what I mean 429 00:29:41,591 --> 00:29:47,072 The United States has never stopped overthrowing governments that He has no qualms about hindering his interests 430 00:29:47,096 --> 00:29:50,552 And Bibi Netanyahu also hinders America's interests 431 00:29:50,943 --> 00:29:54,152 , in the framework of the political discourse of the United States 432 00:29:52,375 --> 00:29:54,875 {\an8}"Mikey Bergman - consultant for prisoner exchange negotiations" 433 00:29:54,176 --> 00:29:59,226 You don't want hostages To be mixed with "Israeli policies". 434 00:29:59,302 --> 00:30:03,427 Because this case causes that Our friends in Congress cannot help us 435 00:30:28,179 --> 00:30:30,848 I think I am here I put myself under a lot of pressure 436 00:30:33,643 --> 00:30:37,274 It doesn't matter how many people I convince 437 00:30:38,006 --> 00:30:39,667 My parents are still there 438 00:30:39,691 --> 00:30:40,692 ... and 439 00:30:43,611 --> 00:30:48,108 And as we speak They were imprisoned there 440 00:30:48,622 --> 00:30:50,641 Or maybe worse... 441 00:30:52,453 --> 00:30:53,996 ... and 442 00:30:56,207 --> 00:31:00,878 And there is no guarantee that What I do here is enough 443 00:31:10,054 --> 00:31:12,567 The news indicates that An agreement is being formed 444 00:31:12,701 --> 00:31:16,578 , a plan to release fifty hostages including women and children 445 00:31:16,802 --> 00:31:20,323 American and Israeli authorities announced that there is cautious optimism in this case 446 00:31:20,347 --> 00:31:25,962 But they acknowledged the number of Palestinian and Israeli prisoners which are going to be released is still not finalized 447 00:31:25,986 --> 00:31:28,065 The Ministry of Health of Gaza announced 448 00:31:28,089 --> 00:31:33,118 that more than 14 thousand people during Israel's retaliatory measures killed 449 00:31:34,245 --> 00:31:38,499 There is no guarantee that Get them out of there alive 450 00:31:38,875 --> 00:31:42,336 How to end this story Still unrecognizable 451 00:31:44,867 --> 00:31:48,277 "kidnapped" 452 00:31:53,308 --> 00:31:56,841 I am happy that the Americans are doing something 453 00:31:57,153 --> 00:32:04,139 Because the hostages have been around for a long time They are in captivity 454 00:32:04,399 --> 00:32:06,826 It seems that the others are not in a hurry 455 00:32:07,185 --> 00:32:08,190 ...you know 456 00:32:08,561 --> 00:32:10,941 Every day is like torture for the prisoners 457 00:32:11,187 --> 00:32:15,523 , no one considers this issue At least it's not like this here 458 00:32:18,038 --> 00:32:22,556 There have been opinions and conversations that say We will win this war 459 00:32:22,649 --> 00:32:27,215 And as long as all these people To be taken hostage 460 00:32:27,240 --> 00:32:29,016 It means that We just lost the war 461 00:32:29,088 --> 00:32:30,131 yes 462 00:32:34,892 --> 00:32:38,892 "House of Yehuda and Khaya - Kibbutz Shumerat" 463 00:32:41,705 --> 00:32:46,432 Some American families have plans Participate for Passover 00:32:54,121 But it is not a problem ...there must be something 467 00:32:55,197 --> 00:32:57,721 Something to hope for - yes - 468 00:32:57,746 --> 00:33:00,255 Hopeful plans to be done 469 00:33:00,423 --> 00:33:04,559 It is very important that the conditions are normal 470 00:33:05,503 --> 00:33:10,016 In a situation similar to ours One has to distract him somehow 471 00:33:11,008 --> 00:33:14,571 This is what I say "Let it go, I'm not thinking about it now" 472 00:33:14,595 --> 00:33:17,016 And this is the way of Judah He faces that problem 473 00:33:17,041 --> 00:33:23,092 From the thought of Liat and Aviv being possible No matter how scary they are, come out 474 00:33:25,147 --> 00:33:29,655 He wants these senators and congressmen listen to him 475 00:33:30,618 --> 00:33:34,535 But I don't know to what extent It can affect them 476 00:33:35,355 --> 00:33:36,697 who knows 477 00:33:44,874 --> 00:33:48,874 "week five" 478 00:33:52,299 --> 00:33:58,771 The main members of Netanyahu's cabinet They ignited the fire of the situation 479 00:33:58,795 --> 00:34:04,878 And from Hamas attacks They misused it to advance their anti-Arab goals 480 00:34:05,060 --> 00:34:08,249 So far, thousands of Palestinians have been killed 481 00:34:08,273 --> 00:34:13,079 And among the families of prisoners present in Gaza There is a lot of fear and concern 482 00:34:13,103 --> 00:34:17,626 that Israel's actions will cause that They can no longer meet their loved ones 483 00:34:20,683 --> 00:34:23,101 Israel is crazy people gathered in his government board 484 00:34:24,171 --> 00:34:30,637 And they are because of the death of people They have no regrets for honoring God 485 00:34:31,505 --> 00:34:36,039 And I want to be honest This is the last thing I want right now 486 00:34:36,064 --> 00:34:38,156 That some people are killed for such a reason 487 00:34:38,280 --> 00:34:43,350 Because religious fanatic views It has blinded some politicians 488 00:34:43,768 --> 00:34:46,079 Although this opinion Many may not like it 489 00:34:46,103 --> 00:34:47,288 But this is my opinion 490 00:34:47,312 --> 00:34:50,166 Sir, good to see you, and good luck - Thank you very much - 491 00:34:50,190 --> 00:34:52,645 Sir, what is the pronunciation of your last name? - Benin - 492 00:34:52,666 --> 00:34:54,930 John? - ...the conditions are terrible - 493 00:34:55,455 --> 00:34:56,894 Hello 494 00:34:58,032 --> 00:34:59,967 Can I say hello? 495 00:35:00,292 --> 00:35:02,193 Hello, hello! hello 496 00:35:02,195 --> 00:35:03,747 I am Ahmed Mansour 497 00:35:03,829 --> 00:35:05,640 If you want to talk to someone let me know 498 00:35:05,167 --> 00:35:07,667 {\an8}"Ahmed Mansour - Supporter of Palestinian interests" 499 00:35:05,664 --> 00:35:09,484 We are with the Congress leaders regarding the ceasefire ...we have an appointment, but 500 00:35:11,113 --> 00:35:13,314 ...maybe you can - A moment, a moment - 501 00:35:13,338 --> 00:35:16,550 First of all It is an honor to meet you 502 00:35:17,009 --> 00:35:20,196 I understand your pain and suffering You don't have to say anything 503 00:35:20,220 --> 00:35:22,639 Me until now I lost half of my family 504 00:35:25,350 --> 00:35:26,393 Judas? 505 00:35:27,019 --> 00:35:29,539 You do not know my true political opinions 506 00:35:29,563 --> 00:35:33,685 And if you knew, you would understand that We both have many ideas in common 507 00:35:34,910 --> 00:35:37,651 But for now, enough freedom I don't have it to express them 508 00:35:37,676 --> 00:35:39,572 Because I am supported by a group 509 00:35:39,596 --> 00:35:42,051 And it is necessary according to their instructions to act 510 00:35:42,241 --> 00:35:46,098 But this time Your daughter's feet are falling 511 00:35:46,122 --> 00:35:49,249 ...but you should know that the Israeli army 512 00:35:49,959 --> 00:35:52,377 He does not want the hostages to be released... 513 00:35:52,402 --> 00:35:54,424 They kill most of them 514 00:35:55,403 --> 00:35:57,525 I don't think that is right Let's go this far 515 00:35:57,549 --> 00:35:59,527 I don't know what they want 516 00:35:59,551 --> 00:36:02,205 I don't know that I have such a guess Is it right or not? 517 00:36:02,229 --> 00:36:03,239 But I am worried 518 00:36:03,263 --> 00:36:05,283 The main issue is not the Israeli army 519 00:36:05,307 --> 00:36:06,868 Bibi Netanyahu's problem 520 00:36:06,892 --> 00:36:09,020 Yes, that's right stretch out your hand 521 00:36:10,161 --> 00:36:12,432 Our common points Much more than our differences 522 00:36:12,457 --> 00:36:15,978 Before the events of October 7th I would never shake hands with you 523 00:36:16,068 --> 00:36:18,169 But now you too You understand pain and suffering 524 00:36:18,863 --> 00:36:21,591 They talk about the ceasefire resolution 525 00:36:21,615 --> 00:36:23,885 But that case guarantees the release of prisoners 526 00:36:23,909 --> 00:36:26,304 And I tell them that The bombings must stop 527 00:36:26,328 --> 00:36:28,263 Because this is how they are killed 528 00:36:44,013 --> 00:36:46,240 We want justice We will tell you how 529 00:36:46,264 --> 00:36:51,079 Let them feel the pressure now 530 00:36:51,103 --> 00:36:55,000 !Free Palestine 531 00:36:55,024 --> 00:36:57,752 He must claim to represent the American people 532 00:36:57,776 --> 00:37:00,338 He claims to be a representative of democracy 533 00:37:00,362 --> 00:37:02,423 But these words are funny 534 00:37:02,447 --> 00:37:05,578 Because people speak their words and say that 535 00:37:05,602 --> 00:37:08,596 "Biden, your legacy is genocide" 536 00:37:08,620 --> 00:37:10,849 What is our request? - Truce - 537 00:37:10,873 --> 00:37:12,809 When should it be done? - !right now - 538 00:37:12,833 --> 00:37:14,978 What is our request? - Truce - 539 00:37:15,002 --> 00:37:16,730 When should it be done? - !right now - 540 00:37:16,754 --> 00:37:19,232 What if our wish is not implemented? - !Board the door - 541 00:37:19,256 --> 00:37:21,860 If our request is not implemented? 542 00:37:21,884 --> 00:37:23,926 !Board the door 543 00:37:24,008 --> 00:37:25,554 "Cease fire for the prisoners" 544 00:37:28,867 --> 00:37:31,867 "genocide atmosphere" 545 00:37:33,187 --> 00:37:38,585 I am here with my Palestinian friends and colleagues Call for a cease-fire 546 00:37:38,609 --> 00:37:44,464 Mass killing of Palestinian citizens of the Gaza Strip It will not make Israel's Jews more secure 547 00:37:44,489 --> 00:37:50,217 I don't want even one Palestinian My family members should be killed for bloodshed 548 00:37:45,083 --> 00:37:47,283 {\an8} 00:38:31,512 We are currently serving as a professor of Middle East history 560 00:38:31,536 --> 00:38:32,621 Joel Benin 561 00:38:33,164 --> 00:38:34,790 Thank you Julia 562 00:38:35,332 --> 00:38:38,627 Talking to me today is different from other days It's a bit harder 563 00:38:35,792 --> 00:38:37,792 {\an8}"Portland, Oregon" 564 00:38:39,044 --> 00:38:41,352 I think most of you know the story of my nephew 565 00:38:39,792 --> 00:38:41,992 {\an8}"Joel - brother of Judah" 566 00:38:42,046 --> 00:38:44,260 Liat Azili has been taken hostage 567 00:38:44,675 --> 00:38:47,818 But I think we all understand this 568 00:38:47,904 --> 00:38:52,704 The history of Israel/Palestine It has not started since the seventh day of October 569 00:38:52,933 --> 00:38:56,289 during the Arab-Israeli war in 1948 570 00:38:56,313 --> 00:39:01,709 The state of Israel was established While 750 thousand Palestinian Arabs 571 00:39:01,733 --> 00:39:06,388 They fled out of fear or by force Being driven from their land and homes 572 00:39:07,012 --> 00:39:10,125 And the Palestinian society was destroyed 573 00:39:10,201 --> 00:39:14,288 This is what the Palestinians do It is called "Day of Nakbat". 574 00:39:14,746 --> 00:39:21,271 It is impossible for us to know what happened on October 7, 2023 Let's understand what happened between Israel and Palestine 575 00:39:21,295 --> 00:39:23,330 Without understanding the "Day of Nakbat". 576 00:39:23,672 --> 00:39:28,342 Acknowledgment of Nakbat day means Genocide of Israeli Jews 577 00:39:28,366 --> 00:39:30,446 or driving the Jews into the sea 578 00:39:30,470 --> 00:39:32,973 Or even the need to end not to the independence of the Jews 579 00:39:33,431 --> 00:39:36,393 This is an admission of a historical mistake 580 00:39:37,853 --> 00:39:41,209 I would like to emphasize that the statement of history 581 00:39:41,233 --> 00:39:45,202 in a different way than that Have you ever heard? 582 00:39:45,485 --> 00:39:48,113 It means to dehumanize Not the feelings of the Israelis 583 00:39:48,947 --> 00:39:54,051 Oppose what Israel does He is doing it in the Gaza Strip 584 00:39:54,075 --> 00:39:58,290 If we want to be clear Destruction of human society in Gaza 585 00:39:58,832 --> 00:40:01,126 I mean, it was razed to the ground 586 00:40:02,836 --> 00:40:04,955 This is not an anti-Israel issue 587 00:40:10,969 --> 00:40:16,784 Honestly, this was the first time This conflict became personal for me 588 00:40:16,808 --> 00:40:20,907 Well, I was one of Liat's close relatives 589 00:40:20,931 --> 00:40:24,134 And I was also very interested in Aviva 590 00:40:24,158 --> 00:40:28,880 How he takes care of our mother When he comes and visits him 591 00:40:28,904 --> 00:40:31,615 and takes care of everything And of these things 592 00:40:31,782 --> 00:40:36,846 After one direction, my feelings As part of the family members 593 00:40:36,870 --> 00:40:40,144 And of course I want to support the family 594 00:40:41,833 --> 00:40:45,379 And on the other hand, I live here And politically, I disagree with the issue 595 00:40:45,837 --> 00:40:51,009 Listen, Joey, I'm not dating Give discounts to the Palestinians 596 00:40:51,593 --> 00:40:54,614 They should accept the responsibility of their crimes 597 00:40:54,638 --> 00:40:57,099 which is not small 598 00:40:57,474 --> 00:41:02,271 Very well ...but you don't think every day that passes 599 00:41:02,738 --> 00:41:09,445 Israel with what it is doing in the Gaza Strip Does it cause many people to join Hamas? 600 00:41:10,321 --> 00:41:11,839 I don't know, this is a question 601 00:41:11,863 --> 00:41:14,116 This is a good question, I don't know what to say 602 00:41:15,826 --> 00:41:21,266 A very big gap between my opinion And there is the opinion of family members 603 00:41:21,290 --> 00:41:23,881 Since it has been a long time I left Israel 604 00:41:23,906 --> 00:41:29,910 Because it was 1972 that I changed my opinions and views 605 00:41:29,965 --> 00:41:35,720 We were taught that kibbutzim The leader of socialist developments is the state of Israel 606 00:41:36,221 --> 00:41:39,433 And we came to Kibbutz Lahav in September 1970 607 00:41:39,933 --> 00:41:42,521 I can't ignore this point ...which is that kibbutz 608 00:41:42,545 --> 00:41:46,122 Literally on the ruins of... Three Palestinian villages were built 609 00:41:46,148 --> 00:41:48,942 ...in short, something like 610 00:41:50,110 --> 00:41:54,090 There was a racist norm... 611 00:41:54,114 --> 00:41:57,803 which may or may not be seen Either it could be said or not 612 00:41:58,327 --> 00:42:00,912 That covered everything 613 00:42:01,455 --> 00:42:03,089 This was devastating 614 00:42:03,457 --> 00:42:06,760 And one of the reasons I left there This is what I always thought 615 00:42:06,784 --> 00:42:10,929 If they don't solve this problem A terrible thing like this will happen 616 00:42:11,256 --> 00:42:13,567 Not allowed to reach anywhere Not enough help has been given 617 00:42:13,591 --> 00:42:16,404 The destruction of Gaza City is huge 618 00:42:16,428 --> 00:42:20,533 And Palestinian families once again They found themselves homeless 619 00:42:20,557 --> 00:42:22,267 Assad Bey, Al Jazeera reporter 620 00:42:26,563 --> 00:42:28,763 When we look back now 621 00:42:28,825 --> 00:42:36,198 Almost all kibbutzim were built on areas which was once owned by the Palestinians 622 00:42:37,824 --> 00:42:44,056 So how can this be the case? Adapted to socialist ideology? 623 00:42:44,081 --> 00:42:46,333 And it is very difficult to do this 624 00:42:47,834 --> 00:42:51,905 When Khaya and I were in the early seventies We decided to come to Israel 625 00:42:52,229 --> 00:42:56,819 The issue was to enter the kibbutz Let's build a socialist society 626 00:42:56,843 --> 00:42:58,970 For a better Israeli For a better world 627 00:42:59,804 --> 00:43:05,703 We imagine a common society It consisted of Palestinians and Jews 628 00:43:05,727 --> 00:43:07,912 As from a common land We use 629 00:43:08,772 --> 00:43:12,484 And unfortunately this is the case It did not go as we hoped 630 00:43:13,355 --> 00:43:17,906 And honestly, I am very sad about this 631 00:43:18,823 --> 00:43:25,098 About 15 million people in the distance They live in the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea 632 00:43:25,122 --> 00:43:29,200 And half of them are Jews And half of them are Palestinians 633 00:43:29,224 --> 00:43:31,528 And no one goes anywhere 634 00:43:31,545 --> 00:43:34,107 And we have to find a way to solve this problem 635 00:43:34,131 --> 00:43:40,870 We must address the concerns of the Jews Let's mention the concerns of the Palestinians 636 00:43:40,894 --> 00:43:45,016 To understand each other's humanity and move forward 637 00:43:58,370 --> 00:44:02,370 659 00:47:10,156 --> 00:47:12,382 You are unique, unique 660 00:47:12,407 --> 00:47:15,647 Be my wife and companion for the rest of our lives Be filled with love and creativity 661 00:47:48,440 --> 00:47:51,240 "Sixth week" 662 00:47:51,388 --> 00:47:56,285 It is only expected in a few hours Stop the conflict between Israel and Hamas 663 00:47:56,309 --> 00:48:00,122 This is the first step for the release of prisoners It is on Friday 664 00:48:00,146 --> 00:48:03,575 This morning, the Qatari authorities who , were in charge of mediating this agreement 665 00:48:03,599 --> 00:48:07,599 They announced that the first group consisted of thirteen people consisting of women and children delivered to the Red Cross 666 00:48:07,623 --> 00:48:08,922 and will be transferred to a safe place 667 00:48:08,946 --> 00:48:12,009 He says that the thirteen captives will return tomorrow at 4 o'clock 668 00:48:12,633 --> 00:48:16,546 And Hamas announced that 50 hostages including women and children who are captives in Gaza 669 00:48:16,570 --> 00:48:18,766 will be released according to the terms of this agreement 670 00:48:18,790 --> 00:48:23,204 On the other hand, Israel has nearly 150 Palestinians will release 671 00:48:23,798 --> 00:48:26,880 Hi guys, I was listening to the news 672 00:48:26,905 --> 00:48:32,773 Yes, the first phase will start in the coming days 673 00:48:32,798 --> 00:48:34,801 It will be a gradual process 674 00:48:34,826 --> 00:48:37,750 Until this moment, Liat's name It is not in the list of the first day 675 00:48:39,939 --> 00:48:44,617 We hope that Liat also in the future Be included among the names 676 00:48:45,032 --> 00:48:48,185 The government is still trying to return it 677 00:48:48,514 --> 00:48:49,648 Well? 678 00:48:49,673 --> 00:48:51,176 ok, good 679 00:48:55,452 --> 00:49:00,099 And according to the Israeli media, this issue It will also include Israeli ground and air attacks 680 00:49:00,123 --> 00:49:04,604 If all goes according to plan, the Israeli prisoners Every day they will be released by Hamas 681 00:49:04,628 --> 00:49:07,260 But it is necessary to say Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu 682 00:49:07,285 --> 00:49:09,149 expressly declared that This war is not over 683 00:49:09,173 --> 00:49:12,361 , this is just a stop Not a lasting ceasefire 684 00:49:13,108 --> 00:49:14,961 He is a stupid idiot 685 00:49:14,986 --> 00:49:19,653 Nearly 240 people during the Hamas attack They were kidnapped, including 40 children 686 00:49:46,643 --> 00:49:50,239 Ah, Ophri is standing there I was not conscious 687 00:49:51,714 --> 00:49:52,964 Hello! 688 00:49:52,989 --> 00:49:55,189 {\an8}"Ofrey - the eldest son of Liat and Aviv" 689 00:49:54,455 --> 00:49:56,290 hello dear 690 00:49:58,004 --> 00:49:59,941 I am very happy to see you 691 00:50:01,614 --> 00:50:06,350 Neta told you what to do with us in America? 692 00:50:06,375 --> 00:50:08,032 no - What's wrong? - 693 00:50:08,057 --> 00:50:10,184 Neta did not tell me anything 694 00:50:14,656 --> 00:50:17,742 Among those three people Neta is experiencing more difficult conditions 695 00:50:18,576 --> 00:50:25,399 And I don't know about going to America Telling the story is a good idea or not 696 00:50:26,167 --> 00:50:30,087 In a way, I think this has caused it to empty himself 697 00:50:30,672 --> 00:50:33,580 But in another way 698 00:50:34,078 --> 00:50:38,095 He has to repeat this over and over again And face it all the time 699 00:50:38,930 --> 00:50:41,434 Neta thinks that she is going to be killed 700 00:50:41,458 --> 00:50:45,729 And I think this case as a trauma It will stay with him until the end of his life 701 00:50:47,204 --> 00:50:51,767 I looked at Neta and My hand went to him to hug him 702 00:50:51,792 --> 00:50:55,793 My heart was broken Because his body language defined everything 703 00:50:56,018 --> 00:50:58,218 {\an8}"Talma - Aviv's mother" 704 00:50:57,096 --> 00:50:58,712 right - My heart was broken - 705 00:50:58,737 --> 00:51:00,671 I saw that I could not help him 706 00:51:00,696 --> 00:51:03,576 Hugging him did not fix anything 707 00:51:03,601 --> 00:51:04,614 Yes, that's right 708 00:51:07,772 --> 00:51:10,472 We are at the service of Thelma Atzili 709 00:51:10,497 --> 00:51:14,158 With their grandchildren, Aya and Ofrey 710 00:51:14,183 --> 00:51:18,829 Thelma, while your son Aviv and Liat Still being held hostage 711 00:51:19,133 --> 00:51:22,160 How do you feel about this complicated day? 712 00:51:22,928 --> 00:51:27,822 I am happy for every hostage that is released 713 00:51:27,847 --> 00:51:30,484 I am happy for their families 714 00:51:30,509 --> 00:51:35,912 And this case gives us hope that one day All hostages return home safe and sound 715 00:51:35,937 --> 00:51:37,457 How about you, Aya and Ofrey? 716 00:51:37,482 --> 00:51:43,669 You are also concerned about this issue and the release of 13 hostages Do you get energy and hope? 717 00:51:43,781 --> 00:51:47,661 Yes, we also try Be happy for the families of those released 718 00:51:45,210 --> 00:51:47,410 {\an8}"Aya - Daughter of Liat and Aviv" 719 00:51:48,913 --> 00:51:51,389 If I don't lie, we are a bit jealous 720 00:51:51,414 --> 00:51:52,671 Ophry? 721 00:51:53,290 --> 00:51:57,940 I really miss them And I want to see them from the bottom of my heart 722 00:51:57,965 --> 00:52:03,087 And I know that my father is not among the first group of those released 723 00:52:03,112 --> 00:52:07,346 That's why I hope my mother will come back soon 724 00:52:08,613 --> 00:52:12,197 This is our wish Thank you very much 725 00:52:13,775 --> 00:52:17,793 On October 8th, we left Nir Oz 726 00:52:18,174 --> 00:52:21,741 And all I wanted was that go back home 727 00:52:22,909 --> 00:52:26,288 The situation of the hotel was similar to Majlis Khatm 728 00:52:26,830 --> 00:52:30,125 Everyone just sits in one place all day And they did nothing 729 00:52:30,959 --> 00:52:35,064 You know, maybe sometimes fun were doing 730 00:52:35,088 --> 00:52:37,090 Like picnics and vacations 731 00:52:37,590 --> 00:52:39,526 But we were not on vacation 732 00:52:39,550 --> 00:52:43,013 We are dealing with a tragedy And we want to face it 733 00:52:43,869 --> 00:52:45,840 , on the seventh of October 734 00:52:46,222 --> 00:52:48,686 I felt violated 735 00:52:49,186 --> 00:52:51,305 And I can't do anything 736 00:52:51,329 --> 00:52:53,423 I was completely passive 737 00:52:55,859 --> 00:53:02,744 In short, I wanted from the passive state Switch to active mode 738 00:53:04,325 --> 00:53:07,294 A kibbutz is like a grandmother 739 00:53:07,318 --> 00:53:09,932 And he is really sick now 740 00:53:09,956 --> 00:53:12,125 And in the hospital 741 00:53:12,750 --> 00:53:16,939 But let's not go to it Or don't help him 742 00:53:16,963 --> 00:53:19,605 ...I think so 743 00:53:19,979 --> 00:53:22,969 I think this will cause it I should be ashamed of myself 744 00:53:27,015 --> 00:53:30,685 That's why we are against the kibbutz We have a sense of responsibility 745 00:53:40,611 --> 00:53:45,616 I feel that this is the way through it I can help as much as possible 746 00:53:49,079 --> 00:53:53,124 I miss them And I stop myself from calling them 747 00:53:55,043 --> 00:53:57,521 that I don't think stupidly 748 00:53:57,545 --> 00:53:59,505 For example, where is this, where is that? 749 00:54:05,011 --> 00:54:06,554 I am worried 750 00:54:18,868 --> 00:54:20,421 "week seven" 751 00:54:20,550 --> 00:54:24,091 Everyone is stressed these days 752 00:54:24,621 --> 00:54:26,821 {\an8}"Ohad Miller - Israeli army liaison" 753 00:54:25,979 --> 00:54:28,491 But there is good news about Liat 754 00:54:28,516 --> 00:54:31,351 From a very sensitive information source Good news is coming 755 00:54:32,264 --> 00:54:36,327 That's why they don't tell us all the details 756 00:54:36,608 --> 00:54:37,869 But the case is progressing 757 00:54:37,894 --> 00:54:43,512 It also takes time to list the hostages that We are going to get them free 758 00:54:43,961 --> 00:54:45,978 I think so 759 00:54:46,108 --> 00:54:48,198 For example, how much, two weeks? 760 00:54:48,241 --> 00:54:53,575 No, I mean earlier than this Maybe even until tonight 761 00:55:05,024 --> 00:55:06,472 Hello Judah 762 00:55:06,616 --> 00:55:08,206 hello good morning 763 00:55:08,511 --> 00:55:11,819 We got the list of names 764 00:55:11,844 --> 00:55:13,317 ...and unfortunately 765 00:55:13,384 --> 00:55:15,707 Liat's name was not in today's list either 766 00:55:19,649 --> 00:55:21,292 well - uhm - 767 00:55:21,536 --> 00:55:23,631 I hope the situation will be different tomorrow 768 00:55:24,396 --> 00:55:25,479 ok 769 00:55:34,091 --> 00:55:38,289 The Israeli government should Take the responsibility of returning the prisoners 770 00:55:38,313 --> 00:55:44,336 And if it is going to be for every captive Freeing ten or twenty Palestinians is not important to me 771 00:55:44,360 --> 00:55:46,630 I can tell you that , off camera 772 00:55:46,654 --> 00:55:47,673 ...behind the scenes 773 00:55:47,697 --> 00:55:50,383 No, what are you saying behind the camera? Finish it! 774 00:55:50,407 --> 00:55:52,094 Or maybe I didn't tell you, let it go 775 00:55:52,118 --> 00:55:54,054 My wife is yelling at me 776 00:55:54,078 --> 00:55:55,121 goodbye 777 00:55:55,454 --> 00:55:58,976 To say something to someone behind the camera ... it does not mean that 778 00:55:59,000 --> 00:56:00,793 OK, you can say it more respectfully 779 00:56:01,686 --> 00:56:03,187 I said respectfully 780 00:56:12,429 --> 00:56:14,754 Thank you all for participating in this video call 781 00:56:14,807 --> 00:56:18,519 Everyone here knows that The Americans haven't come home yet 782 00:56:18,896 --> 00:56:21,298 and it is very disappointing that this issue does not happen 783 00:56:19,167 --> 00:56:21,667 {\an8}"Roger Carstens - US Department of State" 784 00:56:22,436 --> 00:56:24,798 , you know, basically ...we all think that 785 00:56:23,750 --> 00:56:26,250 {\an8}"Meeting of families of Israeli-American prisoners" 786 00:56:25,117 --> 00:56:28,162 Being an American Currently, it is considered an advantage 787 00:56:28,445 --> 00:56:32,992 It seems that it works It works against our children and families 788 00:56:33,368 --> 00:56:35,512 , in short, if you put yourself in the shoes of Hamas 789 00:56:35,536 --> 00:56:41,018 You were probably trying to get American citizens Hold to maintain leverage in negotiations 790 00:56:41,042 --> 00:56:45,638 Roger, from this point of view and to the extent that It is related to Hamas, it may be the same 791 00:56:45,762 --> 00:56:50,569 Israel, in relation to the demands of Hamas He has the upper hand 792 00:56:50,593 --> 00:56:54,597 According to the number of released prisoners 793 00:56:55,098 --> 00:56:58,244 And that topic has not been discussed here yet 794 00:56:58,268 --> 00:57:00,996 But I think this is a big problem It is avoided 795 00:57:01,020 --> 00:57:04,166 If it takes time to count the number Finally 796 00:57:04,190 --> 00:57:07,226 All the prisoners that Israel has They are inevitably released 797 00:57:07,250 --> 00:57:09,897 Let's get this over with ... because 798 00:57:10,321 --> 00:57:13,574 However, some of the hostages are injured 799 00:57:13,950 --> 00:57:17,197 You know, when Gilad Shalit , was taken hostage 800 00:57:17,321 --> 00:57:22,917 The next day, Hamas announced that They demand the release of a thousand captives 801 00:57:23,459 --> 00:57:30,276 And you know how many captives five years later We traded for Gilad Shalit? 802 00:57:30,300 --> 00:57:33,219 One thousand and two? - One thousand and twenty seven people - 803 00:57:33,677 --> 00:57:35,565 Don't let us wait five years 804 00:57:35,589 --> 00:57:37,824 Only if things go awry Will we pay for it? 805 00:57:37,848 --> 00:57:40,244 So let's give it a price Let's start messing up tomorrow 806 00:57:40,268 --> 00:57:43,424 , listen Maybe this word is unpleasant 807 00:57:43,448 --> 00:57:46,208 But I say that Hamas is doing well 808 00:57:46,232 --> 00:57:49,426 Do they want to torture us? They are doing it in the best way 809 00:57:49,526 --> 00:57:52,289 , they don't only have captives 810 00:57:52,313 --> 00:57:59,954 But the families of all people They have the most special and disgusting form of torture at their disposal 811 00:58:00,621 --> 00:58:04,017 And I expect exactly the same from Hamas 812 00:58:04,041 --> 00:58:08,063 But I don't expect the same from the Israeli government 813 00:58:08,087 --> 00:58:10,714 and also from the US government 814 00:58:11,299 --> 00:58:12,818 I agree with you in this matter 815 00:58:12,842 --> 00:58:17,516 And in this call, your desire I feel the urgency of implementing this task 816 00:58:17,805 --> 00:58:19,992 This is why it is so important to talk to you 817 00:58:20,206 --> 00:58:21,563 Thank you all 818 00:58:23,894 --> 00:58:25,321 No, a trap 819 00:58:26,897 --> 00:58:28,024 hello dear 820 00:58:28,274 --> 00:58:33,766 Honestly, I talked to the kids And they said that I should come to Eilat 821 00:58:34,091 --> 00:58:34,702 well 822 00:58:34,727 --> 00:58:38,201 In short, I want to try and Change my flight 823 00:58:38,526 --> 00:58:40,887 If you heard anything about tomorrow let me know 824 00:58:40,911 --> 00:58:42,389 OK, I'll let you know 825 00:58:42,413 --> 00:58:43,615 Okay - ok - 826 00:58:43,640 --> 00:58:45,267 so see you - I'll talk to you later - 827 00:58:45,291 --> 00:58:46,625 ok, bye - Goodbye - 828 00:59:00,103 --> 00:59:02,981 It's always time 829 00:59:04,199 --> 00:59:06,202 Everything begins to unfold... 830 00:59:07,002 --> 00:59:11,359 And because of the situation we are in now Most of all, I have stress and anxiety 831 00:59:13,050 --> 00:59:16,397 There is a sense of guilt I am here now 832 00:59:16,422 --> 00:59:19,801 I drink my coffee, I eat my lunch 833 00:59:19,825 --> 00:59:21,869 But where is my sister now? 834 00:59:22,703 --> 00:59:25,432 Who is it before? where are you Are you in a house? 835 00:59:25,456 --> 00:59:27,767 In a cave? Has he eaten or not? 836 00:59:27,791 --> 00:59:29,210 Does he have his glasses with him or not? 837 00:59:30,503 --> 00:59:33,964 If he comes back one day How does it come back? 838 00:59:35,174 --> 00:59:38,844 It has so much power that Take care of his children? 839 00:59:43,099 --> 00:59:46,161 I think all of them now They are really in survival mode 840 00:59:46,185 --> 00:59:49,480 Everyone is tired, everyone is very disappointed 841 00:59:55,027 --> 00:59:56,653 They do not have good feelings 842 01:00:09,001 --> 01:00:11,511 Well, today's list is determined 843 01:00:11,691 --> 01:00:14,730 And Liat is still not among them 844 01:00:14,843 --> 01:00:17,033 I really don't have the patience for these games 845 01:00:17,058 --> 01:00:18,786 What are they waiting for? 846 01:00:18,811 --> 01:00:20,714 I mean, don't worry, this is all a game 847 01:00:21,815 --> 01:00:25,462 A fight between two school bullies to see who is stronger 848 01:00:25,487 --> 01:00:27,072 I think this is the case 849 01:00:27,117 --> 01:00:33,201 And it is ugly for a civilized country Get involved in such a nonsense story 850 01:00:33,245 --> 01:00:37,139 Don't worry, this is very illogical 851 01:00:38,571 --> 01:00:41,865 I believe that Hamas does not have them 852 01:00:42,699 --> 01:00:44,410 I think someone else has taken them hostage 853 01:00:44,577 --> 01:00:46,577 I got a letter from a lawyer 854 01:00:46,601 --> 01:00:49,401 That says directly It has information from the US Department of State 855 01:00:49,448 --> 01:00:52,543 that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs by name He demanded Liat's release 856 01:00:52,876 --> 01:00:57,189 That the Ministry of Foreign Affairs by name Liat's release has been requested 857 01:00:58,413 --> 01:00:59,973 It does not mean that Hamas 858 01:00:59,998 --> 01:01:02,881 But Ohad said if America Name someone specifically 859 01:01:02,906 --> 01:01:04,498 They put him on the list - No! 860 01:01:04,522 --> 01:01:06,298 Ohad did not say this - Why did he say that? 861 01:01:06,322 --> 01:01:11,330 He said if you have to Ask for Liat's name 862 01:01:11,354 --> 01:01:12,767 ...this is very different from 863 01:01:12,791 --> 01:01:14,899 Well, you think Biden is going Talk to Yahya Senvar personally? 864 01:01:14,924 --> 01:01:18,876 If your head is on the phone I don't want to talk to you 865 01:01:18,901 --> 01:01:21,479 do you know what This is one of those comments I don't want to hear anything about it 866 01:01:21,504 --> 01:01:22,632 ...okay but - I'm doing something! 867 01:01:22,657 --> 01:01:25,780 So tell me what you are doing Then I will wait for it to finish 868 01:01:25,805 --> 01:01:26,621 This is new news 869 01:01:26,646 --> 01:01:32,486 But the expectations were that Liat Be among the first 50 people 870 01:01:33,409 --> 01:01:36,362 According to what I was told 871 01:01:36,629 --> 01:01:39,525 Yes, but the people who told you this 872 01:01:39,549 --> 01:01:41,592 They don't know who you are 873 01:01:43,594 --> 01:01:46,072 ...I am also angry that they were captured 874 01:01:46,096 --> 01:01:49,433 Okay, what are you doing now? Do you disagree with me? 875 01:01:49,975 --> 01:01:52,287 Because you say what you have It does not fit with reason 876 01:01:52,311 --> 01:01:54,188 Of course it is 877 01:01:55,189 --> 01:01:57,650 My way of thinking is different from yours, it's not a problem 878 01:01:58,275 --> 01:02:00,837 And your way of thinking is different from mine No problem again! 879 01:02:00,861 --> 01:02:02,881 You should not criticize me for this 880 01:02:02,905 --> 01:02:05,072 And I do not criticize you for your opinions 881 01:02:05,097 --> 01:02:07,144 I do not agree with you But I do not criticize you 882 01:02:07,178 --> 01:02:10,691 You are free to your opinion And I am independent of my own opinions 883 01:02:11,368 --> 01:02:13,351 I want the hostages to be released They are just playing 884 01:02:13,384 --> 01:02:15,975 Yes, of course they are playing - Okay, so I don't make excuses - 885 01:02:15,999 --> 01:02:17,341 I want them back 886 01:02:17,375 --> 01:02:19,950 Where did you find out about their considerations? 887 01:02:20,203 --> 01:02:21,203 The grave of their father 888 01:02:21,507 --> 01:02:23,151 I am trying to do something 889 01:02:23,175 --> 01:02:25,404 Tell me it's a good effort Don't say how useful these efforts are 890 01:02:25,428 --> 01:02:28,598 ...no, but - I'm tired of this nonsense! 891 01:03:25,612 --> 01:03:28,612 01:04:30,844 "Is Liat's name on the release list tonight?" 910 01:04:31,217 --> 01:04:32,344 yes 911 01:04:35,265 --> 01:04:36,892 He sent a happy cat 912 01:04:39,061 --> 01:04:42,999 I was preparing myself That he will not come back 913 01:04:43,023 --> 01:04:46,714 I didn't even think that he might come back 914 01:04:47,361 --> 01:04:48,905 ... and 915 01:04:49,724 --> 01:04:51,464 Now he is coming back 916 01:04:51,532 --> 01:04:53,709 Now I have both my daughters 917 01:05:04,511 --> 01:05:06,356 We are at your service with breaking news 918 01:05:06,380 --> 01:05:10,542 Hamas holds an American hostage Freed from Gaza 919 01:05:10,566 --> 01:05:14,587 , an American woman named Liat Binnin Along with fifteen other people 920 01:05:14,811 --> 01:05:17,409 Eight more Americans still They were taken hostage in Gaza 921 01:05:17,433 --> 01:05:21,246 This transfer literally It is being done at the last possible moment 922 01:05:21,270 --> 01:05:27,860 In exchange for this exchange, Israel is supposed to Release 30 Palestinians from Israeli prisons 923 01:05:28,402 --> 01:05:33,425 Thus, the total number of freed hostages During the ceasefire, it reached 97 people 924 01:05:33,449 --> 01:05:36,535 And that means about 150 people They are still in custody 925 01:05:37,202 --> 01:05:39,723 They are now on their way back to Israel 926 01:05:39,747 --> 01:05:41,749 They left the Gaza Strip safely 927 01:05:43,840 --> 01:05:45,280 This is it 928 01:05:47,944 --> 01:05:52,211 His face says it "Go away, I don't want to be here" 929 01:05:54,710 --> 01:05:56,901 Did they inform you? - yes sir - 930 01:05:56,930 --> 01:05:58,290 Okay then 931 01:05:58,474 --> 01:06:02,819 I want to tell you on behalf of myself and my family 932 01:06:02,844 --> 01:06:06,040 I thank you from the bottom of my heart for the efforts you made 933 01:06:06,064 --> 01:06:09,223 That my daughter be released safe and sound 934 01:06:10,796 --> 01:06:13,308 Well, let me tell you something 935 01:06:13,675 --> 01:06:16,717 , I understand you I lost a daughter myself 936 01:06:16,903 --> 01:06:18,947 Excuse me for a moment Khaya, Khaya? 937 01:06:20,788 --> 01:06:25,143 I want, I want my wife to come too 938 01:06:25,168 --> 01:06:26,635 and talk to you 939 01:06:27,680 --> 01:06:29,055 definitely 940 01:06:29,212 --> 01:06:30,650 Say hello to the president 941 01:06:32,312 --> 01:06:33,312 Hello! 942 01:06:34,254 --> 01:06:39,702 Hello, I called to tell you that I was happy to hear the news of your daughter's release 943 01:06:39,727 --> 01:06:42,526 It is certainly a source of joy and peace 944 01:06:43,164 --> 01:06:48,911 Honestly, I'm glad you played an important role You were responsible for his return 945 01:06:50,724 --> 01:06:55,721 Because I think if it wasn't for you and the United States That girl never came back to us 946 01:06:56,428 --> 01:06:58,140 I also lost a daughter 947 01:06:58,402 --> 01:06:59,708 I lost a son 948 01:06:59,733 --> 01:07:01,353 I know how it feels 949 01:07:01,381 --> 01:07:04,900 I can only imagine How difficult it was for you 950 01:07:04,925 --> 01:07:07,470 I am sure he is eager to see his three children 951 01:07:07,626 --> 01:07:09,521 Oh, it's over 952 01:07:09,545 --> 01:07:13,089 I am sure he wants to see them as soon as possible And I will see him as soon as possible 953 01:07:14,216 --> 01:07:16,152 I have very good news to tell you 954 01:07:16,176 --> 01:07:19,322 Liat Binin is in Egypt, correct and healthy 955 01:07:19,346 --> 01:07:20,723 crossed the border 956 01:07:21,306 --> 01:07:23,075 I talked to his parents 957 01:07:23,099 --> 01:07:26,102 , they are very grateful And everything is going well 958 01:07:26,144 --> 01:07:28,814 She will soon be at home with her three children 959 01:07:50,460 --> 01:07:52,144 hello dear 960 01:07:52,223 --> 01:07:54,685 i am fine 961 01:07:56,410 --> 01:07:57,887 I'm fine 962 01:07:59,190 --> 01:08:01,813 You were supposed to be at my house on Saturday 963 01:08:01,846 --> 01:08:04,613 Thank God you weren't there 964 01:08:04,998 --> 01:08:06,495 beer 965 01:08:09,913 --> 01:08:12,284 They didn't tell me 966 01:08:12,433 --> 01:08:15,224 You called him and told him "Tal, Pashu, come here soon?" 967 01:08:15,273 --> 01:08:18,596 No, it is not a problem for them to tell me stay there 968 01:08:18,621 --> 01:08:20,396 Liat, I arrived today Yeni yesterday 969 01:08:20,421 --> 01:08:22,190 really - yes - 970 01:08:22,690 --> 01:08:24,688 I was in New York Dad called and said 971 01:08:24,712 --> 01:08:27,634 "Niya Eilat, come to the hospital" 972 01:08:30,235 --> 01:08:33,444 I knew, I knew you would come 973 01:08:34,891 --> 01:08:36,901 I brought you something - what did you bring me - 974 01:08:36,926 --> 01:08:38,084 your glasses 975 01:08:38,109 --> 01:08:39,531 Evil! 976 01:08:39,690 --> 01:08:41,400 I hope it's the same as you used to 977 01:08:42,220 --> 01:08:43,823 Not the ones I used to make 978 01:08:43,847 --> 01:08:45,594 Honestly, we didn't find the rest 979 01:08:45,619 --> 01:08:47,626 did you go to my house - yes - 980 01:08:48,503 --> 01:08:50,063 Is my house on fire? 981 01:08:50,088 --> 01:08:51,923 yes - no - 982 01:08:52,898 --> 01:08:55,543 Guys, I have to say this 983 01:08:55,567 --> 01:08:57,873 I told the children before 984 01:08:59,264 --> 01:09:01,892 I have no problem 985 01:09:02,120 --> 01:09:04,006 Liat, it's not like this for everyone 986 01:09:04,040 --> 01:09:06,355 I know, I know 987 01:09:06,536 --> 01:09:10,720 I don't want to talk about Aviv now, okay? 988 01:09:10,825 --> 01:09:11,909 ok 989 01:09:34,520 --> 01:09:37,581 When I came to the hospital 990 01:09:37,606 --> 01:09:39,977 Asking my husband's name 991 01:09:40,002 --> 01:09:47,149 I also said Aviv Atzili ...Then I saw a similar reaction from them 992 01:09:47,983 --> 01:09:50,491 After hearing Aviv's name I saw a concern in their eyes 993 01:09:52,048 --> 01:09:53,868 ...but we know that Aviv is going 994 01:09:54,336 --> 01:09:55,639 what are you going to do 995 01:10:00,051 --> 01:10:02,354 We know he is fine 996 01:10:14,313 --> 01:10:15,647 all right 997 01:10:17,163 --> 01:10:18,935 I don't want to cry 998 01:10:42,799 --> 01:10:48,447 In the last hours, we found out that Aviv Azili did not survive 999 01:10:48,471 --> 01:10:51,951 His wife Liat was released yesterday 1000 01:10:51,975 --> 01:10:53,996 When you talk to these families 1001 01:10:54,020 --> 01:10:58,499 You hear how they are about the news of freedom Happy family members 1002 01:10:58,523 --> 01:11:03,779 And how to hear the news of his death Other family members are sad 1003 01:11:19,658 --> 01:11:24,890 during the last two months We lost a lot 1004 01:11:24,915 --> 01:11:27,766 We are our beloved and valuable countrymen we lost 1005 01:11:27,791 --> 01:11:29,851 And that is why we are here today 1006 01:11:30,352 --> 01:11:32,119 We lost our house 1007 01:11:32,172 --> 01:11:35,884 ...both physically 1008 01:11:35,909 --> 01:11:39,360 And spiritually And much more than words 1009 01:11:40,751 --> 01:11:45,830 ...I personally feel that 1010 01:11:46,973 --> 01:11:51,377 I entered a very deep crisis of despair.. 1011 01:11:51,402 --> 01:11:57,690 So that the ability to imagine the future I lost this place 1012 01:11:57,808 --> 01:12:00,951 falling and drowning It is very easy to get lost in this world 1013 01:12:00,976 --> 01:12:04,966 But I still look at what we have 1014 01:12:05,280 --> 01:12:09,792 The grief of losing Avio is heavy Hard and exhausting 1015 01:12:09,817 --> 01:12:15,162 And I choose to try and I will deal with the things that are left of him 1016 01:12:15,187 --> 01:12:20,588 First of all, with his way of looking at the world And the way he spent his life 1017 01:12:20,959 --> 01:12:23,287 And most importantly 1018 01:12:23,312 --> 01:12:27,531 With the most valuable things that He left it as a souvenir for me 1019 01:12:27,556 --> 01:12:30,031 Ofri, Neta and Aya 1020 01:12:30,073 --> 01:12:33,394 We continue to live 1021 01:12:33,418 --> 01:12:36,212 And we are committed to its way and custom 1022 01:12:36,237 --> 01:12:40,579 To live our lives in the best way 1023 01:12:43,424 --> 01:12:46,658 We are going to get through this quickly 1024 01:12:46,683 --> 01:12:50,496 But all in Nir Oz Know the song of Aviv Atzili 1025 01:12:50,521 --> 01:12:53,702 So dedicated to the worst dancer in the world 1026 01:12:53,727 --> 01:12:57,530 Please join me come on 1027 01:13:01,488 --> 01:13:04,128 Come on, let's go to the others 1028 01:13:09,933 --> 01:13:11,558 You are really something 1029 01:13:16,556 --> 01:13:19,267 Rita, I can't accompany you 1030 01:13:19,292 --> 01:13:21,600 I haven't moved in two months 1031 01:13:26,676 --> 01:13:27,797 Not Rita 1032 01:13:30,294 --> 01:13:31,419 I can't do it 1033 01:13:31,444 --> 01:13:32,836 no problem 1034 01:13:34,013 --> 01:13:36,543 I'm sorry I didn't dance with you 1035 01:13:36,568 --> 01:13:38,858 It's okay, Thelma 1036 01:13:41,225 --> 01:13:44,101 you are unique 1037 01:14:21,893 --> 01:14:25,500 ...I was worried about you too, but 1038 01:14:26,356 --> 01:14:28,000 You were more worried about the children 1039 01:14:28,024 --> 01:14:31,778 Which is completely normal 1040 01:14:31,820 --> 01:14:33,140 I was terrified 1041 01:14:33,905 --> 01:14:36,675 It was very difficult for both sides 1042 01:14:36,699 --> 01:14:39,202 Well, you are my baby 1043 01:14:39,494 --> 01:14:43,887 I know you are the same I had a hard time, you had a hard time 1044 01:14:44,393 --> 01:14:46,644 It was really, really hard 1045 01:14:46,668 --> 01:14:47,805 ...but me 1046 01:14:49,481 --> 01:14:51,929 I was very worried about them 1047 01:14:52,382 --> 01:14:54,444 Do you remember when you were a child? 1048 01:14:54,468 --> 01:14:56,805 I hurt myself every time 1049 01:14:57,553 --> 01:15:00,616 You said that "I'm hurting myself right here." 1050 01:15:00,640 --> 01:15:05,621 And that was the place Something happened to me or vice versa 1051 01:15:05,645 --> 01:15:08,791 And I really hoped that If something bad happens to you 1052 01:15:08,815 --> 01:15:10,108 I feel it too - yes - 1053 01:15:12,819 --> 01:15:14,946 ...yeah, but me 1054 01:15:16,281 --> 01:15:20,428 ...I felt that I had a feeling that Ofrey was fine 1055 01:15:20,794 --> 01:15:23,213 I was very worried about Neta - uhm - 1056 01:15:24,247 --> 01:15:27,250 Because I knew that they were going to his room 1057 01:15:29,419 --> 01:15:32,506 ...and I was very worried that he wouldn't 1058 01:15:33,548 --> 01:15:36,610 Don't let something happen to them 1059 01:15:36,634 --> 01:15:38,112 ...or for Aviv, because 1060 01:15:38,136 --> 01:15:42,033 ...I could not cope with him 1061 01:15:42,057 --> 01:15:45,655 I couldn't do without Aviv Cope with the grief of losing a child 1062 01:15:47,896 --> 01:15:51,709 I don't think I can handle my feelings express well 1063 01:15:51,733 --> 01:15:54,212 You can't express your feelings at all 1064 01:15:54,236 --> 01:15:57,215 But apart from that I will do whatever I can 1065 01:15:57,239 --> 01:16:02,136 To provide security and well-being for you and your children 1066 01:16:23,181 --> 01:16:24,182 ok 1067 01:16:26,435 --> 01:16:28,395 You have the right to cry too, you know that 1068 01:16:29,067 --> 01:16:30,331 the first time 1069 01:16:30,355 --> 01:16:32,648 yes i know i know 1070 01:16:44,545 --> 01:16:47,545 Kibbutz Nir Oz 1071 01:16:56,380 --> 01:16:58,352 Haven't you been here before? - no - 1072 01:16:59,540 --> 01:17:01,076 Whose is this? 1073 01:17:02,019 --> 01:17:05,318 Netas's had just arrived here 1074 01:17:05,521 --> 01:17:07,853 oh god 1075 01:17:09,849 --> 01:17:12,266 Totally hot 1076 01:17:16,458 --> 01:17:18,792 This is my neighbor's house 1077 01:17:21,350 --> 01:17:23,270 Has anyone returned? 1078 01:17:24,393 --> 01:17:25,787 no 1079 01:17:27,654 --> 01:17:30,196 It's so sad - very - 1080 01:17:39,804 --> 01:17:42,577 Is this your class? - yes - 1081 01:17:45,241 --> 01:17:46,800 How many students did you have? 1082 01:17:46,959 --> 01:17:48,918 Twenty seven 1083 01:18:05,912 --> 01:18:09,239 This Aviva and this Liat 1084 01:18:12,846 --> 01:18:15,491 Isn't it strange to see this? - Why, it's so strange - 1085 01:18:15,516 --> 01:18:16,756 who was killed 1086 01:18:17,484 --> 01:18:18,832 isn't it? - yes - 1087 01:18:19,091 --> 01:18:22,121 "Killed or kidnapped" "!Return the hostages now! 1088 01:18:26,263 --> 01:18:28,864 I still have a lot of anger 1089 01:18:29,099 --> 01:18:31,285 And I want revenge 1090 01:18:31,670 --> 01:18:33,351 and a sense of despair 1091 01:18:34,261 --> 01:18:37,153 I still have all these feelings ...but still 1092 01:18:38,135 --> 01:18:40,391 I am speaking for myself 1093 01:18:40,454 --> 01:18:43,570 Well, what do you think? 1094 01:18:43,594 --> 01:18:49,915 If you miss something What do you think should be done now? 1095 01:18:49,940 --> 01:18:51,779 Kill everyone? - No! 1096 01:18:51,804 --> 01:18:54,731 Shall we deport them? Or sign an agreement? 1097 01:18:54,756 --> 01:18:58,797 Something that allows us all live here 1098 01:18:58,821 --> 01:19:00,940 That's it ...but on the contrary 1099 01:19:00,965 --> 01:19:04,811 But first they have to release the hostages 1100 01:19:05,041 --> 01:19:07,335 This is what bothers me the most 1101 01:19:31,554 --> 01:19:33,430 !stop the war 1102 01:19:33,455 --> 01:19:36,383 , simultaneously with the escalation of Israeli attacks in Gaza 1103 01:19:36,607 --> 01:19:40,569 Anti-war slogans echo in Tel Aviv 1104 01:19:40,884 --> 01:19:45,240 Protesters in front of the headquarters of the Israeli army They demanded an immediate ceasefire 1105 01:19:43,798 --> 01:19:45,798 {\an8}, if you condemn a war" It's like you condemned all wars 1106 01:19:47,607 --> 01:19:54,076 All of us are still mourning the dead And we are the hostages of the 7th of October 1107 01:19:54,200 --> 01:20:01,065 But we also mourn the dead in Gaza They are killed day and night 1108 01:20:01,483 --> 01:20:04,368 But in a country attacked by Hamas , damaged 1109 01:20:04,392 --> 01:20:09,073 These protests show a deep divide It is among the community of Israel 1110 01:20:09,621 --> 01:20:12,158 All these people are against the state of Israel 1111 01:20:12,225 --> 01:20:14,948 All these people are supporters of Hamas You are also a fan of Hamas 1112 01:20:22,605 --> 01:20:25,729 My thoughts on Israel's response 1113 01:20:25,754 --> 01:20:29,877 And the events that are happening in Gaza are very complicated 1114 01:20:31,266 --> 01:20:32,743 This is terrible 1115 01:20:33,062 --> 01:20:35,102 It's really terrible 1116 01:20:38,421 --> 01:20:45,496 People say we should not allow it for humanitarian aid to enter Gaza 1117 01:20:45,520 --> 01:20:48,696 And hearing these words is really terrible 1118 01:20:48,856 --> 01:20:52,938 I don't care that this work It allows Hamas to continue the fight 1119 01:20:52,963 --> 01:20:56,092 People should not die of hunger Now it doesn't matter who or where they are 1120 01:20:57,392 --> 01:20:59,144 but 1121 01:21:04,021 --> 01:21:06,990 In the same way 1122 01:21:10,015 --> 01:21:15,107 It is not right to attack people's houses and take them hostage 1123 01:21:47,505 --> 01:21:51,175 President Biden called you a "survivor". 1124 01:21:51,634 --> 01:21:53,320 Does this word sound familiar to you? 1125 01:21:53,344 --> 01:21:54,637 Do you think it is the right word? 1126 01:21:55,346 --> 01:21:57,014 ...this word 1127 01:21:57,932 --> 01:22:00,035 It feels weird - uhm - 1128 01:22:00,059 --> 01:22:03,121 I mean with myself I have many problems 1129 01:22:00,542 --> 01:22:02,775 {\an8} 01:23:03,289 "But don't worry, we won't hurt you" 1148 01:23:03,790 --> 01:23:08,503 And that person who took me out of the house He took me to his family's house 1149 01:23:10,755 --> 01:23:12,691 To his mother and sister 1150 01:23:12,715 --> 01:23:15,736 And they really took good care of me 1151 01:23:15,760 --> 01:23:18,530 I mean, they realized that I was shocked 1152 01:23:18,554 --> 01:23:19,948 ...and that 1153 01:23:20,865 --> 01:23:22,173 I was very sad... 1154 01:23:22,217 --> 01:23:25,329 I didn't know what happened to my child or Aviv 1155 01:23:25,854 --> 01:23:31,534 It's a very complicated thing that you When you were just taken hostage 1156 01:23:31,558 --> 01:23:36,214 Immediately with a high rate You encountered human sympathy and empathy 1157 01:23:36,238 --> 01:23:38,073 Yeah, it's really confusing 1158 01:23:42,077 --> 01:23:43,374 ...we 1159 01:23:49,002 --> 01:23:50,879 We were captives 1160 01:23:51,629 --> 01:23:55,401 Obviously, it is not easy to overcome this issue 1161 01:23:55,425 --> 01:23:58,502 And I know that I was very lucky 1162 01:24:00,013 --> 01:24:03,325 But I said to myself, these are human beings too 1163 01:24:03,349 --> 01:24:05,410 And that I can communicate with them 1164 01:24:05,434 --> 01:24:10,214 ...and I don't have a problem 1165 01:24:10,976 --> 01:24:14,193 If I want to communicate with someone... 1166 01:24:14,703 --> 01:24:18,100 They kept saying that Our duty is to protect you 1167 01:24:18,132 --> 01:24:22,778 And to keep you healthy Until you are freed in an exchange 1168 01:24:22,803 --> 01:24:26,495 I mean, they say this From the first day 1169 01:24:26,572 --> 01:24:27,615 right 1170 01:24:28,332 --> 01:24:30,960 And is there anything you have learned from them? 1171 01:24:33,128 --> 01:24:38,694 Well, a very, very religious look and being principled 1172 01:24:38,718 --> 01:24:44,115 They kept saying that From east to west here 1173 01:24:44,139 --> 01:24:46,726 Everything should be a Palestinian land 1174 01:24:47,101 --> 01:24:49,872 And that all the Jews should leave there 1175 01:24:52,857 --> 01:24:55,878 And we were talking about it ...and one of them said that 1176 01:24:55,902 --> 01:25:00,865 Well, yeah, maybe the two-state idea." "It should be a good solution 1177 01:25:02,489 --> 01:25:03,954 "at least temporarily" 1178 01:25:03,978 --> 01:25:08,505 'til we take over the world" "And all people join Islam 1179 01:25:08,848 --> 01:25:11,351 Do you think they learned something from you? That surprised them? 1180 01:25:11,375 --> 01:25:12,672 I think yes 1181 01:25:12,696 --> 01:25:13,711 For example, what? 1182 01:25:14,253 --> 01:25:21,844 They did not know that the Jews are Israelis How do you see our relationship with Israel? 1183 01:25:22,280 --> 01:25:26,535 Or, for example, many Israelis They say about Palestine 1184 01:25:26,660 --> 01:25:30,684 Well, they have so many countries. "Why don't they go live somewhere else? 1185 01:25:30,812 --> 01:25:36,376 Well, no, it can't be like that They don't want to be Syrian or Egyptian or Jordanian 1186 01:25:36,400 --> 01:25:39,779 They are Palestinians, from here 1187 01:25:40,279 --> 01:25:43,777 ...and I think they have the same feeling 1188 01:25:44,801 --> 01:25:49,306 to the Israeli Jews Having the same feeling 1189 01:25:49,330 --> 01:25:54,561 And that they keep asking me "Why do you think this is yours?" 1190 01:25:54,585 --> 01:26:00,446 And I think if it was before October 7th Peace could be a possible option 1191 01:26:00,490 --> 01:26:02,826 But now there is no such possibility 1192 01:26:03,094 --> 01:26:08,867 In the Middle East, our way of life It cannot be like this 1193 01:26:08,891 --> 01:26:09,892 uhm 1194 01:26:11,166 --> 01:26:13,204 Do you say this to yourself and your family? 1195 01:26:13,228 --> 01:26:15,106 I mean, who is this addressed to? 1196 01:26:15,606 --> 01:26:17,817 addressed to all 1197 01:26:28,383 --> 01:26:31,383 "It's time" 1198 01:26:33,354 --> 01:26:35,557 I came here to hug you 1199 01:26:37,267 --> 01:26:40,023 Thank you for everything 1200 01:26:40,597 --> 01:26:43,042 Thank you for gaining the strength to be here 1201 01:26:43,619 --> 01:26:44,745 It was not easy at all 1202 01:26:44,770 --> 01:26:46,002 thank you 1203 01:26:49,017 --> 01:26:54,484 I can feel your strength It gives us strength 1204 01:26:54,721 --> 01:26:57,217 You are exaggerating - No, it's true - 1205 01:26:58,788 --> 01:27:01,168 I want to tell you something dear 1206 01:27:01,193 --> 01:27:05,676 That you are able to be here today , you have 1207 01:27:05,701 --> 01:27:10,419 It is the only glimmer of hope that we have to be able to Let's raise the next generation here and in peace 1208 01:27:10,444 --> 01:27:13,943 Thank you very much for your strength and courage 1209 01:27:13,968 --> 01:27:19,578 , also from your honesty, and most importantly For transferring hope. thank you 1210 01:27:21,121 --> 01:27:23,597 , on the 7th of October in Kibbutz Nir Oz 1211 01:27:23,698 --> 01:27:27,299 My aunt Carmela and her child Noya were killed 1212 01:27:27,494 --> 01:27:31,243 For 9 months I fought to save the lives of prisoners 1213 01:27:31,268 --> 01:27:34,377 And also to rebuild our country 1214 01:27:35,891 --> 01:27:39,161 My name is Liat Atzili A teacher from Nir Oz 1215 01:27:39,186 --> 01:27:42,561 , the widow of Aviv Atzili and a returned captive 1216 01:27:46,353 --> 01:27:48,213 Was it hard to tell you? - yes - 1217 01:27:48,788 --> 01:27:49,918 It is very terrible 1218 01:27:57,121 --> 01:27:59,525 "Stop war, build peace" 1219 01:27:59,859 --> 01:28:01,876 I am Rola Hardal 1220 01:28:01,900 --> 01:28:04,335 A Palestinian from al-Baqi'a 1221 01:28:05,206 --> 01:28:09,259 Last year, hundreds of thousands of Israelis Demonstration for democracy 1222 01:28:09,584 --> 01:28:13,251 And hundreds of thousands of people now They are demonstrating for re-election 1223 01:28:13,276 --> 01:28:17,815 But until the root of the problems do not identify 1224 01:28:17,840 --> 01:28:23,377 As long as for freedom and universal democracy Let's not fight 1225 01:28:23,401 --> 01:28:26,127 We will continue to be trapped in the spiral of destruction 1226 01:28:26,151 --> 01:28:29,584 But I know that My freedom as a Palestinian 1227 01:28:29,608 --> 01:28:35,413 It means freedom for Jews and Israelis will be 1228 01:28:36,733 --> 01:28:40,709 The joint journey we started today 1229 01:28:40,734 --> 01:28:44,080 It will be a journey of hope and peace 1230 01:28:59,610 --> 01:29:02,610 "three months later" 1231 01:29:05,917 --> 01:29:10,917 "Yod Vashem Holocaust Memorial - Jerusalem" 1232 01:29:21,459 --> 01:29:22,459 all right 1233 01:29:22,567 --> 01:29:26,276 Boys and girls, what do you see? 1234 01:29:27,368 --> 01:29:28,960 "Liat's High School Class" 1235 01:29:28,984 --> 01:29:31,562 A wall was built What kind of wall was it? 1236 01:29:32,483 --> 01:29:35,252 A dividing wall What did he separate? 1237 01:29:35,276 --> 01:29:39,584 A wall between Jews and Poles and Germans 1238 01:29:39,608 --> 01:29:41,710 What is the name of that place? 1239 01:29:41,734 --> 01:29:44,085 Ghetto, this is the wall of the ghetto 1240 01:29:44,109 --> 01:29:49,118 They built this wall in Poland To keep the Jews in the ghetto 1241 01:29:49,194 --> 01:29:54,168 from outside the wall Poland witnessed the ghetto on fire 1242 01:29:54,192 --> 01:29:57,835 And they pretended that nothing happened 1243 01:29:57,859 --> 01:30:04,168 A poem that expresses The paradox of people's lives in that period 1244 01:30:04,192 --> 01:30:08,365 When a disaster on the other side of the wall happening 1245 01:30:09,188 --> 01:30:11,645 Okay, let's continue 1246 01:30:33,810 --> 01:30:35,817 I found a very big pine cone 1247 01:30:38,525 --> 01:30:43,703 How we treat the other side of the fence it bothers me 1248 01:30:44,317 --> 01:30:48,085 Once, my heart was burning for me Aviv said 1249 01:30:48,109 --> 01:30:51,364 "Do you feel sorry for yourself?" 1250 01:30:51,388 --> 01:30:53,389 "Do you think your life is hard?" 1251 01:30:53,414 --> 01:30:56,071 "Think about what's going on on the other side of the fence" 1252 01:30:56,827 --> 01:31:03,451 I got angry with him And I said, what does this have to do with my life? 1253 01:31:05,056 --> 01:31:07,006 Now I understand the connection 1254 01:31:08,237 --> 01:31:11,879 I personally saw that What's going on on the other side of the fence? 1255 01:31:12,123 --> 01:31:14,854 And my way of looking can't be the same anymore 1256 01:31:16,225 --> 01:31:19,043 We live near the fence 1257 01:31:19,068 --> 01:31:22,144 But no one cares What's going on on the other side of the fence? 1258 01:31:25,276 --> 01:31:33,276 Today, that fence has acquired a deeper significance 1259 01:31:40,419 --> 01:31:45,703 ...and there is a penalty for not accepting this issue 1260 01:31:55,958 --> 01:33:55,958